[Edge-computing] [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting

Csatari, Gergely (Nokia - HU/Budapest) gergely.csatari at nokia.com
Wed Jan 9 09:53:30 UTC 2019


Hi,

Sure I agree, that a test deployment is not always following the production, but at least we should

  1.  describe what are the differneces and what is the reason for that
  2.  provide feedback for the production definition if there are new findings during the test definition, execution

Thanks,
Gerg0

From: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com <zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>
Sent: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 10:36 AM
To: Csatari, Gergely (Nokia - HU/Budapest) <gergely.csatari at nokia.com>
Cc: opnfv-tech-discuss <opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>; opnfv-tsc <opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>; edge-computing <edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>
Subject: Re: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting

Yes, I think we should try that.

When I was doing the edge Pharos Spec, which is a draft for now, I definitely consulted the whitepaper, but was trying to do as less modification about the original Pharos spec as possible. Because I thought a test environment could not actually follow the real environment. And edge pharos spec is only one possible scenario that could be picked from edge site definitions.
I'll see how to modify it and we  can discuss in the following edge cloud meetings.

Best,
Qihui
________________________________
China Mobile Research Institute
(+86) 13810659120

From: Gergely Csatari<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>
Date: 2019-01-09 17:13
To: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>; fuqiao<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>; beth.cohen<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>; Peret, Adrian (Nokia - FI/Espoo)<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>; julienjut<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>; haojingbo<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>; ildiko<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>; paul-andre.raymond<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>; trevor.cooper<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>; cristina.pauna<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>; xiaohua.zhang<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>; Bob.Monkman<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>; deepak.s<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>; asayeed<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>; Tina.Tsou<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>; klaus.mehler<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>; periyasamy.palanisamy<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>; hu.jie<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>; kliu<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>; wanglu<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>; pvaanane<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>; fanyamei<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>; glenn.seiler<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>; huang.shuquan<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>; adrien.lebre<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>; pierre.lynch<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>; pj<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>; valentin.boucher<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>; kan.hong<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>; claudio_serra<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>; acm<mailto:acm at research.att.com>; Tikkanen, Viktor (Nokia - FI/Espoo)<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>; simple_hlw<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>; kailun.qin<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>; mark.beierl<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>; Manuel Buil<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>
CC: opnfv-tech-discuss<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>; opnfv-tsc<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>; edge-computing<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>
Subject: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting
Hi,

Thanks for the links.

I still think, that we should keep the Edge Pharos Specs [1<https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EC/Edge+cloud?preview=/20745277/32015361/Edge%20Cloud_Pharos%20Spec_StarlingX.pdf>] and the Edge Cloud Site definitions [2<https://opnfv-edgecloud.readthedocs.io/en/stable-gambia/development/requirements/requirements.html#edge-sites-conditions-deployment-scenarios>] in the whitepaper consistent.

Br,
Gerg0

[1]: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EC/Edge+cloud?preview=/20745277/32015361/Edge%20Cloud_Pharos%20Spec_StarlingX.pdf
[2]: https://opnfv-edgecloud.readthedocs.io/en/stable-gambia/development/requirements/requirements.html#edge-sites-conditions-deployment-scenarios

From: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com> <zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>>
Sent: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 10:07 AM
To: Csatari, Gergely (Nokia - HU/Budapest) <gergely.csatari at nokia.com<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>>; fuqiao <fuqiao at chinamobile.com<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>>; beth.cohen <beth.cohen at verizon.com<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>>; Peret, Adrian (Nokia - FI/Espoo) <adrian.peret at nokia.com<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>>; julienjut <julienjut at gmail.com<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>>; haojingbo <haojingbo at huawei.com<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>>; ildiko <ildiko at openstack.org<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>>; paul-andre.raymond <paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>>; trevor.cooper <trevor.cooper at intel.com<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>>; cristina.pauna <cristina.pauna at enea.com<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>>; xiaohua.zhang <xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>>; Bob.Monkman <Bob.Monkman at arm.com<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>>; deepak.s <deepak.s at linux.intel.com<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>>; asayeed <asayeed at redhat.com<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>>; Tina.Tsou <Tina.Tsou at arm.com<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>>; klaus.mehler <klaus.mehler at ericsson.com<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>>; periyasamy.palanisamy <periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>>; hu.jie <hu.jie at zte.com.cn<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>>; kliu <kliu at cavium.com<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>>; wanglu <wanglu at chinamobile.com<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>>; pvaanane <pvaanane at redhat.com<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>>; fanyamei <fanyamei at chinamobile.com<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>>; glenn.seiler <glenn.seiler at windriver.com<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>>; huang.shuquan <huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>>; adrien.lebre <adrien.lebre at inria.fr<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>>; pierre.lynch <pierre.lynch at keysight.com<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>>; pj <pj at acgcc.com<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>>; valentin.boucher <valentin.boucher at kontron.com<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>>; kan.hong <kan.hong at 99cloud.net<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>>; claudio_serra <claudio_serra at jabil.com<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>>; acm <acm at research.att.com<mailto:acm at research.att.com>>; Tikkanen, Viktor (Nokia - FI/Espoo) <viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>>; simple_hlw <simple_hlw at 163.com<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>>; kailun.qin <kailun.qin at intel.com<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>>; mark.beierl <mark.beierl at dell.com<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>>; Manuel Buil <mbuil at suse.com<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>>
Cc: opnfv-tech-discuss <opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>>; opnfv-tsc <opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>>; edge-computing <edge-computing at lists.openstack.org<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>>
Subject: Re: RE: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting

Sure.

I have uploaded the slides onto our wiki home page: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EC/Edge+cloud
you can find them at the bottom of the page -> "Related discussion links and slides" -> under "January 2019 Plugfest slides"

Best,
Qihui
________________________________
China Mobile Research Institute
(+86) 13810659120

From: Csatari, Gergely (Nokia - HU/Budapest)<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>
Date: 2019-01-09 16:40
To: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>; fuqiao<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>; beth.cohen<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>; Peret, Adrian (Nokia - FI/Espoo)<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>; julienjut<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>; haojingbo<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>; ildiko<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>; paul-andre.raymond<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>; trevor.cooper<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>; cristina.pauna<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>; xiaohua.zhang<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>; Bob.Monkman<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>; deepak.s<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>; asayeed<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>; Tina.Tsou<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>; klaus.mehler<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>; periyasamy.palanisamy<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>; hu.jie<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>; kliu<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>; wanglu<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>; pvaanane<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>; fanyamei<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>; glenn.seiler<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>; huang.shuquan<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>; adrien.lebre<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>; pierre.lynch<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>; pj<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>; valentin.boucher<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>; kan.hong<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>; claudio_serra<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>; acm<mailto:acm at research.att.com>; Tikkanen, Viktor (Nokia - FI/Espoo)<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>; simple_hlw<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>; kailun.qin<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>; mark.beierl<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>; Manuel Buil<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>
CC: opnfv-tech-discuss<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>; opnfv-tsc<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>; edge-computing<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>
Subject: RE: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting
Hi,

Is it possible to get the presented materials in some form?

Thanks,
Gerg0

From: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com> <zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>>
Sent: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 2:29 AM
To: fuqiao <fuqiao at chinamobile.com<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>>; beth.cohen <beth.cohen at verizon.com<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>>; Peret, Adrian (Nokia - FI/Espoo) <adrian.peret at nokia.com<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>>; julienjut <julienjut at gmail.com<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>>; haojingbo <haojingbo at huawei.com<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>>; Csatari, Gergely (Nokia - HU/Budapest) <gergely.csatari at nokia.com<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>>; ildiko <ildiko at openstack.org<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>>; paul-andre.raymond <paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>>; trevor.cooper <trevor.cooper at intel.com<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>>; cristina.pauna <cristina.pauna at enea.com<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>>; xiaohua.zhang <xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>>; Bob.Monkman <Bob.Monkman at arm.com<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>>; deepak.s <deepak.s at linux.intel.com<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>>; asayeed <asayeed at redhat.com<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>>; Tina.Tsou <Tina.Tsou at arm.com<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>>; klaus.mehler <klaus.mehler at ericsson.com<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>>; periyasamy.palanisamy <periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>>; hu.jie <hu.jie at zte.com.cn<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>>; kliu <kliu at cavium.com<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>>; wanglu <wanglu at chinamobile.com<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>>; pvaanane <pvaanane at redhat.com<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>>; fanyamei <fanyamei at chinamobile.com<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>>; glenn.seiler <glenn.seiler at windriver.com<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>>; huang.shuquan <huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>>; adrien.lebre <adrien.lebre at inria.fr<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>>; pierre.lynch <pierre.lynch at keysight.com<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>>; pj <pj at acgcc.com<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>>; valentin.boucher <valentin.boucher at kontron.com<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>>; kan.hong <kan.hong at 99cloud.net<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>>; claudio_serra <claudio_serra at jabil.com<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>>; acm <acm at research.att.com<mailto:acm at research.att.com>>; Tikkanen, Viktor (Nokia - FI/Espoo) <viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>>; simple_hlw <simple_hlw at 163.com<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>>; kailun.qin <kailun.qin at intel.com<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>>; mark.beierl <mark.beierl at dell.com<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>>; Manuel Buil <mbuil at suse.com<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>>
Cc: opnfv-tech-discuss <opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>>; opnfv-tsc <opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>>; edge-computing <edge-computing at lists.openstack.org<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>>
Subject: Re: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Time changed for this week's meeting

Hello edge cloud team,

This week's meeting will be held together with the plugfest sessions.

Time: Jan. 9th, 2019, Wednesday, UTC 07:30 ~ 09:00
Zoom link: https://zoom.us/j/457096090

Best,
Qihui
________________________________
China Mobile Research Institute
(+86) 13810659120

发件人: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>
发送时间: 2018-12-26 09:05
收件人: fuqiao<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>; beth.cohen<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>; adrian.peret<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>; julienjut<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>; haojingbo<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>; gergely.csatari<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>; ildiko<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>; paul-andre.raymond<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>; trevor.cooper<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>; cristina.pauna<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>; xiaohua.zhang<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>; Bob.Monkman<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>; deepak.s<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>; asayeed<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>; Tina.Tsou<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>; klaus.mehler<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>; periyasamy.palanisamy<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>; hu.jie<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>; kliu<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>; wanglu<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>; pvaanane<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>; fanyamei<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>; glenn.seiler<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>; huang.shuquan<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>; adrien.lebre<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>; pierre.lynch<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>; pj<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>; valentin.boucher<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>; kan.hong<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>; claudio_serra<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>; acm<mailto:acm at research.att.com>; viktor.tikkanen<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>; simple_hlw<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>; kailun.qin<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>; mark.beierl<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>; Manuel Buil<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>
抄送: opnfv-tech-discuss<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>; opnfv-tsc<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>; edge-computing<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>
主题: Re: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Canceled:Edge Cloud Bi-weekly Meeting
As a lot of us are on vacation, today's meeting has been canceled.

________________________________
China Mobile Research Institute
(+86) 13810659120

发件人: zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com<mailto:zhaoqihui at chinamobile.com>
发送时间: 2018-12-25 14:38
收件人: fuqiao<mailto:fuqiao at chinamobile.com>; beth.cohen<mailto:beth.cohen at verizon.com>; adrian.peret<mailto:adrian.peret at nokia.com>; julienjut<mailto:julienjut at gmail.com>; haojingbo<mailto:haojingbo at huawei.com>; gergely.csatari<mailto:gergely.csatari at nokia.com>; ildiko<mailto:ildiko at openstack.org>; paul-andre.raymond<mailto:paul-andre.raymond at b-yond.com>; trevor.cooper<mailto:trevor.cooper at intel.com>; cristina.pauna<mailto:cristina.pauna at enea.com>; xiaohua.zhang<mailto:xiaohua.zhang at windriver.com>; Bob.Monkman<mailto:Bob.Monkman at arm.com>; deepak.s<mailto:deepak.s at linux.intel.com>; asayeed<mailto:asayeed at redhat.com>; Tina.Tsou<mailto:Tina.Tsou at arm.com>; klaus.mehler<mailto:klaus.mehler at ericsson.com>; periyasamy.palanisamy<mailto:periyasamy.palanisamy at ericsson.com>; hu.jie<mailto:hu.jie at zte.com.cn>; kliu<mailto:kliu at cavium.com>; wanglu<mailto:wanglu at chinamobile.com>; pvaanane<mailto:pvaanane at redhat.com>; fanyamei<mailto:fanyamei at chinamobile.com>; glenn.seiler<mailto:glenn.seiler at windriver.com>; huang.shuquan<mailto:huang.shuquan at 99cloud.net>; adrien.lebre<mailto:adrien.lebre at inria.fr>; pierre.lynch<mailto:pierre.lynch at keysight.com>; pj<mailto:pj at acgcc.com>; valentin.boucher<mailto:valentin.boucher at kontron.com>; kan.hong<mailto:kan.hong at 99cloud.net>; claudio_serra<mailto:claudio_serra at jabil.com>; acm<mailto:acm at research.att.com>; viktor.tikkanen<mailto:viktor.tikkanen at nokia.com>; simple_hlw<mailto:simple_hlw at 163.com>; kailun.qin<mailto:kailun.qin at intel.com>; mark.beierl<mailto:mark.beierl at dell.com>; Manuel Buil<mailto:mbuil at suse.com>
抄送: opnfv-tech-discuss<mailto:opnfv-tech-discuss at lists.opnfv.org>; opnfv-tsc<mailto:opnfv-tsc at lists.opnfv.org>; edge-computing<mailto:edge-computing at lists.openstack.org>
主题: Re: Re: [opnfv-tech-discuss] [edge cloud] Canceled:Edge Cloud Bi-weekly Meeting
Hello Edge Cloud Team,

Merry Christmas & Happy Vacation~~

Best,
Qihui
________________________________
China Mobile Research Institute
(+86) 13810659120
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/edge-computing/attachments/20190109/cab9967d/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the Edge-computing mailing list